Extended limited tax liability: Leave stock portfolio in Germany when moving abroad?
🇩🇪 Auf deutsch:
Erweitert beschränkte Steuerpflicht: Aktien-Depot beim Wegzug in Deutschland lassen?
A big question is whether one should keep their stock and ETF portfolio with a German bank in Germany when moving out of Germany or not. Different advisors have very different views on this, so here are my brief notes on the matter!
The keyword at play here is "extended limited tax liability" (erweitert beschränkte Steuerpflicht). Simply put, it means that under certain circumstances, you may still have to pay German taxes on your "German income" if you meet certain criteria.
The whole thing is relatively complicated, so let's start from the beginning: You have to continue paying taxes on certain German income regardless of what happens, i.e., even if you already live abroad. The most common example here is certainly income from renting and leasing – so if you continue to own a property in Germany that you rent out, for example, then you must continue to pay tax on this income in Germany.
So, apart from that, there are of course other types of income and that is where it gets complicated, as the extended limited tax liability may come into play – specifically capital gains in this case.
The keyword at play here is "extended limited tax liability" (erweitert beschränkte Steuerpflicht). Simply put, it means that under certain circumstances, you may still have to pay German taxes on your "German income" if you meet certain criteria.
The whole thing is relatively complicated, so let's start from the beginning: You have to continue paying taxes on certain German income regardless of what happens, i.e., even if you already live abroad. The most common example here is certainly income from renting and leasing – so if you continue to own a property in Germany that you rent out, for example, then you must continue to pay tax on this income in Germany.
So, apart from that, there are of course other types of income and that is where it gets complicated, as the extended limited tax liability may come into play – specifically capital gains in this case.
Extended limited tax liability
Someone falls under the extended limited tax liability if:
- they were subject to unlimited income tax liability for at least five years in the last ten years prior to the end of their unlimited tax liability,
- they become or are resident in a low-tax country, and
- they have substantial economic interests in Germany.
The following notes apply:
- "Low-tax countries" are, for example, certain cantons in Switzerland, the United Arab Emirates, Singapore, Hong Kong, Bulgaria, Hungary, Paraguay, Bolivia; but also countries where there is "remittance-based taxation," i.e., where one receives a kind of preferential tax treatment for foreign income. Overall, the point is that a country levies less than two-thirds of the German income tax burden (in 2025 approx. <18.55%).
- Substantial economic interests are, for example:
- a shareholding of more than 1% in a German corporation
- a share in a German partnership
- domestic income of more than 30% of total income or more than 62,000 euros
- German assets of more than 30% of total assets or more than 154,000 euros.
Now you probably have a hundred questions about this that we could discuss – but the most relevant one here would be how an ETF portfolio would "fit in" here.
The ETF portfolio and extended limited tax liability
If we go through the aspects above with an ETF portfolio, the first question is whether one has moved to a so-called low-tax country at all. So if, for example, you have not moved to a low-tax country (this includes most European countries), then you are essentially already "out" and do not need to read any further.
At the same time, there are many countries where it is not immediately obvious whether they are a low-tax country or not. Thailand, for example, levies quite significant income taxes, but (as of 2025) also has remittance-based taxation for foreign corporate shareholdings. Additionally, there are visa options that also provide for more favorable taxation. So it depends and is overall unclear. In case of doubt, Thailand would therefore be a low-tax country.
Then the next question would arise as to what extent one has "substantial economic interests" due to the ETF portfolio. And these would certainly exist here if one:
At the same time, there are many countries where it is not immediately obvious whether they are a low-tax country or not. Thailand, for example, levies quite significant income taxes, but (as of 2025) also has remittance-based taxation for foreign corporate shareholdings. Additionally, there are visa options that also provide for more favorable taxation. So it depends and is overall unclear. In case of doubt, Thailand would therefore be a low-tax country.
Then the next question would arise as to what extent one has "substantial economic interests" due to the ETF portfolio. And these would certainly exist here if one:
- has more than €62k in income per year from the portfolio (capital gains)
- or has more than €154k in total assets in the German ETF portfolio.
And this is where the big discussion begins, which I had with several tax advisors: Let's assume for a moment that one of the points above applies and we are covered by the extended limited tax liability. However, the fact is that the extended limited tax liability only applies to domestic, "German" income. The big question now is: Is it domestic income if I hold an ETF that is domiciled in Ireland or Luxembourg? That seems relatively unclear to me.
There was this BFH ruling here, in which the plaintiff had moved to Great Britain and claimed remittance-based taxation there. At the same time, she had approx. €30k in capital gains from shares in a German company. The BFH ruled that these €30k capital gains would be subject to extended limited tax liability because they involved shares in a German company.
So far, so "good," but unfortunately this still does not answer the ETF question.
Unfortunately, I could not find any rulings and thus no further indications regarding this. I would tend to suspect that foreign ETFs would not constitute domestic income and one would therefore be "out" again.
Now, however, the question is whether this income continues to not be considered "domestic" if held in a German securities account (Depot). Legally speaking, one would have to assume that the location of the account should not change the nature of the income. Thus, it should be unproblematic.
But is it really? Another and more relevant question might be what happens here in everyday life. Upon moving away, one would specifically have to:
- Inform their custodian bank that they have moved away and that the account should therefore be marked as "tax-exempt" – some banks do not offer this at all and one has to close the account anyway. Then the question of whether to keep the German account or not becomes moot.
- Assuming the custodian bank marks the account as tax-exempt – only then does one have to ask oneself whether to keep the ETFs in the account or transfer them to a foreign account.
- With a German account, the probability seems higher that the tax offices will "look at" the positions and the whole debate about the extended limited tax liability mentioned above begins.
The most relevant point would therefore be 3.) – regardless of who is "right" here, an argument for a foreign account would be that one minimizes the risk that this whole discussion is kicked off in the first place. Some advisors describe it as the German account possibly "awakening desires" on the part of the tax authorities. I don't know if this happens in reality, but it is a relevant argument that one might want to minimize the risk.
Summary
First of all: If you are clearly not moving to a low-tax country, then this is not relevant for you anyway.
Furthermore: If your bank does not offer to let you keep your account when you have moved to your destination country anyway, then this discussion is also moot for you. Incidentally, a non-binding inquiry before your move can be quite worthwhile here, so just ask support whether the bank principally offers that you keep your account after your move to your destination country.
Only if the two points above do not apply to you, then the question arises: Keep ETFs in the German portfolio or not? Unfortunately, there is no clear answer, but one can roughly divide the decision into two arguments:
Furthermore: If your bank does not offer to let you keep your account when you have moved to your destination country anyway, then this discussion is also moot for you. Incidentally, a non-binding inquiry before your move can be quite worthwhile here, so just ask support whether the bank principally offers that you keep your account after your move to your destination country.
Only if the two points above do not apply to you, then the question arises: Keep ETFs in the German portfolio or not? Unfortunately, there is no clear answer, but one can roughly divide the decision into two arguments:
- If you want to absolutely minimize the risk of having any discussions with the tax office regarding extended limited tax liability on your capital gains after your move, then transfer your ETFs and stocks to a foreign securities account (see below).
- If you would rather keep your positions in your German account, e.g., because you find German banks more trustworthy than other banks (which can certainly be relevant), then leave your ETFs and stocks in your German account.
Which foreign securities account?
I have researched foreign brokers for ages; here are my two favorites:
- Interactive Brokers seems to be recommended by far the most often – low fees and almost all countries worldwide are supported as places of residence. Apparently, it is also the case that accounts held by US firms do not (?) fall under the automatic exchange of information between the USA and Germany, so if you are particularly paranoid about possible questions from the tax office, that could be an argument for Interactive Brokers. However, I do not know how relevant that may be in reality.
Account management is free of charge and transaction costs only apply to purchases and sales. It is only a securities account, so you do not get a bank account here. - Swissquote is rarely mentioned but is probably a solid second choice. Attention, the corporate structure of Swissquote has been somewhat confusing since the acquisition of Internaxx: There is the "Swiss" Swissquote with headquarters in Switzerland; this is the "original" version, which is likely less relevant for most people as the fees there are significantly higher. And then there is Swissquote Luxembourg, which was originally another bank with a different name (Internaxx) that was explicitly aimed at expats. I strongly suspect that Swissquote Luxembourg (= Internaxx) is likely the better choice for most people's purposes, as the fees are lower. Theoretically, one also gets a bank account in Luxembourg there, which can also be practical, especially for people whose German bank does not allow for the continuation of the account abroad.
Account management is free while living in the EU, but then costs €15 / month in most other countries.
By the way: Join our Telegram community to exchange ideas with other people who have solved the German exit tax for themselves!
Dr. Oliver Eidel
Ich bin Oliver und bin Unternehmer aus Deutschland - mein bekanntestes Unternehmen ist OpenRegulatory, welches eine Compliance-Software für Medizinprodukte-Hersteller anbietet.
Seit 2025 musste ich mich mit der deutschen Wegzugsteuer auseinandersetzen, da ich nach Thailand auswandern möchte. Auf dieser Webseite teile ich meine Erkenntnisse, die ich mir relativ mühsam durch (teure) Gespräche mit Steuerberatern erarbeiten musste. Hoffentlich spare ich dir dadurch Zeit und Steuerberatergebühren! :)
Seit 2025 musste ich mich mit der deutschen Wegzugsteuer auseinandersetzen, da ich nach Thailand auswandern möchte. Auf dieser Webseite teile ich meine Erkenntnisse, die ich mir relativ mühsam durch (teure) Gespräche mit Steuerberatern erarbeiten musste. Hoffentlich spare ich dir dadurch Zeit und Steuerberatergebühren! :)